A large new study offers clues about how lower-income children can rise up the economic ladder.
Social scientists have made it a priority in recent years to understand upward mobility. They have used tax records and other data to study which factors increase the chances that children who grow up in poverty will be able to escape it as adults.
Education, spanning pre-K through college, seems to play a big role, the research suggests. Money itself is also important: Longer, deeper bouts of poverty can affect children for decades. Other factors — like avoiding eviction, having access to good medical care and growing up in a household with two parents — may also make upward mobility more likely.
Now there is another intriguing factor to add to the list, thanks to a study being published this morning in the academic journal Nature: friendships with people who are not poor.
“Growing up in a community connected across class lines improves kids’ outcome and gives them a better shot at rising out of poverty,” Raj Chetty, an economist at Harvard and one of the study’s four principal authors, told The Times.
The study tries to quantify the effect in several ways. One of the sharpest, I think, compares two otherwise similar children in lower-income households — one who grows up in a community where social contacts mostly come from the lower half of the socioeconomic distribution, and another who grows up in a community where social contacts mostly come from the upper half.
The average difference between the two, in terms of their expected adult outcomes, is significant, the authors report. It’s the same as the gap between a child who grows up in a family that makes $27,000 a year and one who grows up in a family that makes $47,000.
The study is based on a dizzying amount of data, including the Facebook friendships of 72 million people. (You can explore the findings through these charts and maps from The Upshot.)
Robert Putnam — a political scientist who has long studied social interactions, including in his book “Bowling Alone” — said the study was important partly because it hinted at ways to increase upward mobility. “It provides a number of avenues or clues by which we might begin to move this country in a better direction,” he said.
In recent decades, the U.S. has moved in the opposite direction. Rising economic inequality and a shortage of new housing in many communities have helped increase economic segregation. Even within communities, cross-class social interactions seem to have declined.
This chart shows the extent to which Americans segregate themselves by class:
- 1 Mari Bowie’s story
- 2 How churches shine
- 3 The bottom line
- 4 Politics
- 5 War in Ukraine
- 6 Other Big Stories
- 7 Opinions
- 8 Real estate as self care
- 9 What to Cook
- 10 World Through a Lens
- 11 What to Read
- 12 Now Time to Play
Mari Bowie’s story
There seem to be three main mechanisms by which cross-class friendships can increase a person’s chances of escaping poverty, Chetty told me.
The first is raised ambition: Social familiarity can give people a clearer sense of what’s possible. The second is basic information, such as how to apply to college and for financial aid. The third is networking, such as getting a recommendation for an internship.
My colleague Claire Cain Miller, after speaking with the study’s authors in recent weeks, set out to find some real-life examples of its findings. Claire focused on Angelo Rodriguez High School in Fairfield, Calif., a midsize city between Sacramento and Oakland. The school has an unusually high number of cross-class interactions. One of the people whom Claire interviewed was Mari Bowie, a 24-year-old who grew up in a lower-middle-class family that coped with divorce, layoffs and lost homes — and who made friends with richer girls in high school.
“My mom really instilled working hard in us — being knowledgeable about our family history, you have to be better, you have to do better,” Bowie said. “But I didn’t know anything about the SAT, and my friends’ parents signed up for this class, so I thought I should do that. I had friends’ parents look at my personal statements.”
Today, Bowie is a criminal-defense lawyer. She found her job through the friend of one of her high school friends.
How churches shine
Angelo Rodriguez High School is a telling case study because it is more economically and racially diverse than most schools. That diversity is necessary for a high level of socioeconomic integration. But it is not sufficient, the study’s authors say. In some diverse communities, lower- and upper-income Americans lead relatively segregated lives.
In others, cross-class interactions are more common. The study does not contain a complete explanation for the differences. But Claire discovered that the high school had taken intentional steps to connect people.
The school didn’t draw its students from only one community. It instead had an unusually shaped district, including both poorer and richer neighborhoods, and also accepted some students from outside that district’s boundaries. The school’s open architecture also encouraged serendipitous socializing. “Accidental, unstructured interactions between students was a very high priority,” John Diffenderfer, one of the school’s architects, said.
What might increase cross-class interactions elsewhere?
Among the promising possibilities, the researchers say: more housing, including subsidized housing, in well-off areas; more diverse K-12 schools and colleges; and specific efforts — like public parks that draw a diverse mix of families — to encourage interactions among richer and poorer people.
Churches and other religious organizations may have some lessons to teach other parts of society. Although many churches are socioeconomically homogeneous, those with some diversity tend to foster more cross-class interactions than most other social activities. Churchs have lower levels of what the researchers call socioeconomic “friending bias.”
Youth sports, by contrast, have become more segregated, as affluent families have flocked to so-called travel teams.
A successful effort to increase interactions would probably need to address the particular roles of race, too. More racially diverse places tend to have fewer cross-class friendships, the study found.
“Our society is structured in ways that discourage these kinds of cross-class friendships from happening, and many parents, often white, are making choices about where to live and what extracurriculars to put their kids into that make those connections less likely to happen,” Jessica Calarco, a sociologist at Indiana University said. Claire’s story delves into more detail on the role of race.
The stagnation of living standards for working-class and poor Americans is such a giant problem that no single change will solve it. But the explosion of academic research about upward mobility, including this new study, has at least offered a clearer sense of what might help. Social integration seems to play a crucial role.
THE LATEST NEWS
Nancy Pelosi is in Singapore for a tour of Asia. She has not yet said whether she will visit Taiwan.
An emerging group of single-issue voters — anti-vaccine parents — could lift Republicans in the midterm elections.
War in Ukraine
Russia has turned Europe’s largest nuclear power plant into a fortress.
A ship loaded with grain has left Ukraine for the first time since the war began.
Other Big Stories
The water at the Oasis Mobile Home Park in California contains almost 10 times the allowable limit of arsenic. But most residents have no other housing options.
Flooding in Kentucky has killed at least 28 people. Here’s what we know about the victims.
The McKinney fire in Northern California has grown to more than 52,000 acres in two days.
“We just feel helpless”: After school shootings, more American teachers are carrying guns.
Democrats hurt themselves when they respond to crises with fund-raising emails instead of activism, Lara Putnam and Micah Sifry write.
Opposing Donald Trump may cost Liz Cheney her House seat, but there’s value in losing with integrity, Katherine Miller argues.
Metropolitan Diary: Balloons at Queens Plaza and more reader tales of New York City.
Advice from Wirecutter: How to vacation-proof your home.
Lives Lived: On “Star Trek,” Nichelle Nichols portrayed Lieutenant Uhura, an educated technician and one of the first TV roles to show a Black woman in a position of authority. Nichols died at 89.
SPORTS NEWS FROM THE ATHLETIC
Bill Russell is dead at 88: Basketball’s most accomplished player died yesterday, his family announced. He leaves behind an almost unfathomable legacy, Jay King writes. (Here is The Times’s obituary of Russell.)
One in, one out: A judge is expected to announce Cleveland Browns quarterback Deshaun Watson’s suspension today, while the N.F.L.’s last marquee holdout, Deebo Samuel, will be at 49ers camp after agreeing to a three-year, $73.5 million extension.
The Lionesses roar: Chloe Kelly’s goal in the 110th minute led the English women’s national team to a 2-1 win over Germany in the Euros final yesterday, an iconic moment for a program that was banned until 1971.
ARTS AND IDEAS
Real estate as self care
There are many ways to get over heartbreak: taking time to grieve, exercising, spending time with friends, to name a few. But some people are finding solace in something different: investing in real estate.
Many women seeking independence, especially after a breakup or divorce, have discovered emotional empowerment, Jennifer Miller writes in The Times: “And they’ve found a unique support system, where excising relationship ghosts is as important as learning to negotiate interest rates.”
PLAY, WATCH, EAT
What to Cook
Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. — David
P.S. Should you check a bag at the airport? Is a rental car worth the cost? What about insurance? During this summer of travel misery, Times experts will answer your questions. Submit them here.